Ethically Sourced Diamonds & Gemstones
Reviews
Call us on: +44 (0) 208 1111 247
Gemstone engagement rings offer a coloured alternative to diamonds, with sapphire, tanzanite and topaz leading the pack alongside garnet, citrine, peridot and tourmaline. Each stone brings its own colour, price point and level of durability. This guide covers the best options for daily wear, rarity and budget, so you can pick a ring that fits your hand, lifestyle and story.
So you've decided a diamond isn't quite your thing. Excellent call. The world of coloured gemstones is brighter, braver and a good deal more fun to shop, and your future self will thank you every time you catch a flash of blue, violet or sunset pink on your finger. Colour is back with a bang, the old engagement-ring rulebook is being quietly rewritten, and choosing a ring with genuine personality feels like a very happy small rebellion. Think of this as your friendly cheat sheet from someone who's spent years comparing colour grades, hardness ratings and setting styles, and has opinions on all three.
Let's run through the best gemstone engagement rings on offer, what they suit, and where each one earns its place on your finger.
Blue sapphire engagement ring has carried the crown for centuries, and it isn't hard to see why. The colour sits somewhere between midnight sky and cornflower, it scores a very respectable 9 on the Mohs hardness scale, and it handles everyday wear beautifully. Sapphire suits almost every skin tone, and it pairs happily with white gold, yellow gold and rose gold.
It's also a practical choice. Daily knocks, washing up, gardening: sapphire shrugs them all off. If you love the classic feel of a diamond ring but want something with a little more mood, this is your stone.
Found only in the foothills of Mount Kilimanjaro, tanzanite has a violet-blue shimmer that shifts with the light. It's rarer than diamond by a considerable margin, which makes the proposal story rather more interesting.
A tanzanite wedding band sits beautifully alongside a sapphire or diamond solitaire, and many brides now choose tanzanite eternity rings as an anniversary gift rather than the predictable alternative. For a first ring with a difference, try a cushion cut tanzanite on a fine gold shank. A tanzanite wedding band set with a row of small stones offers real wrist appeal, while tanzanite eternity rings also suit women who prefer colour without committing to one large centre stone.
Topaz is often underestimated, which is a shame because it offers huge sparkle for the price. A blue topaz engagement ring gives you that clear, oceanic colour without the aquamarine price tag, and it photographs exceptionally well. London Blue has a moodier, inky quality, while Sky Blue is soft and romantic.
Consider a blue topaz engagement ring in a bezel setting if you're hard on your hands, since topaz sits at around 8 on the hardness scale and benefits from a protective mount. A topaz eternity ring in white gold suits minimalists, while a yellow gold topaz eternity ring feels warmer and more vintage in feel.
If you prefer jewellery that's warm, sunny and a bit glowing, these three are hard to beat.
Yellow sapphire sits somewhere between honey and lemon and brings sapphire's hardness with the cheer of yellow gold. A yellow sapphire ring UK buyers now choose over a yellow diamond costs about a tenth of the price for a similar look, and a yellow sapphire ring UK jewellers can source is far easier to find than it used to be.
A citrine engagement ring glows golden orange and pairs perfectly with yellow gold. It's a lovely autumn-bride stone and remarkably affordable, and a citrine engagement ring ages beautifully in a classic six-claw setting. A garnet engagement ring, by contrast, runs richer, with wine-red tones that feel grown-up and full of character. A pyrope garnet engagement ring looks almost burgundy in candlelight, which is a rather lovely thing to notice on your wedding night.
For something greener, peridot engagement rings bring a soft apple-green hue few other stones offer. A peridot eternity ring works brilliantly as a push present or anniversary gift, and peridot engagement rings look particularly striking in yellow gold. A peridot eternity ring stacked with a plain diamond band creates a lovely contrast for anyone bored of matching sets.
Tourmaline comes in practically every colour of the rainbow. A tourmaline engagement ring in pink and green is a proper conversation starter, while a pink tourmaline ring in rose gold leans far more romantic. If you want bridal softness without going full pink diamond, a pink tourmaline ring is your answer. A tourmaline engagement ring also suits couples who want something truly one of a kind, since no two stones are ever identical.
A Quick Buying Cheat Sheet
• For durability: sapphire first, then topaz
• For rarity: tanzanite, then pink tourmaline
• For budget-friendly sparkle: citrine and blue topaz
• For colour depth: garnet and London Blue topaz
• For a softer, unusual finish: peridot and pink tourmaline
Sapphire is the clear winner for daily wear, scoring 9 on the Mohs hardness scale, just behind diamond at 10. Ruby matches it. Topaz sits at 8 and tanzanite at around 6.5 to 7, so both benefit from bezel or halo settings if you're rough on your hands. Peridot, garnet and pink tourmaline are softer again, which makes them better suited to careful wearers.
Usually, yes. A one carat sapphire, tanzanite or blue topaz engagement ring of good quality will cost a fraction of an equivalent diamond. Garnet, citrine, peridot and tourmaline are cheaper still, often around a tenth of the price. The rare exceptions are investment-grade coloured diamonds, which can exceed white diamonds of the same size. For most couples, a coloured gemstone means a bigger, brighter ring for a smaller bill.
Tanzanite is the rarest widely available engagement stone. It's found in only one small area of northern Tanzania near Mount Kilimanjaro, and supply is finite. Alexandrite and Paraiba tourmaline are rarer still, but both are harder to source in larger sizes and sit at collector-level prices. For a ring that feels genuinely unusual without the waiting list, tanzanite is the sweet spot.
Pick the stone that makes you smile when you glance down at your hand. A ring should feel like yours, not like a safe bet, and coloured gemstones make that wonderfully easy.
Have a browse through our coloured gemstone engagement ring collection to see which stone catches your eye first. That's usually the right one.
